Quote from VVinrar »
I don't like shiv on Cait because she's already a very strong poker. The best item build for DPS output is IE-PD for the early game, any item substitutions should only be if she needs it (BT instead of IE for sustain against high poke comps, for example)
Shiv is for pushing early (which is what cait SHOULD be doing) so i'd say - go for shiv.