I believe the idea is you decide if you want them punished or not, this is independent of what the reports are for or who made them?
Sometimes people are too lazy to change the drop box to the appropriate offence, so I tend not to look at that. And when you review cases, it no longer indicates what the reports were for, so I think the what is largely irrelevant. The fact is, there are reports and your job is to decide if the behaviour in the games you've seen warrant punishment :)
champs who do mainly magic damage prefer magic pen marks and champs who do mainly physical damage prefer armour pen =P
Haven't played much Kha'Zix (read 2 games while he's free this week =P) but in a vacuum I would speculate that the extra damage of 12% missing health on Q > + 50% R and all 3 with 40% shield for 1 second. If 2 R casts isn't enough then I'm not sure how much a third one helps, especially without being able to gte the extra beats in with the evolved claws.
Just one noobs opinion though, so check what Alex Ich or Darien do in the LCS ;)
Just as likely is the self fulfilling prophecy;
"Olaf is bad, so I shouldn't play him in this important game" - which I win
"These trolls, this game will be sketchy, guess I'll just run Olaf and see if he can still carry games 0.o" - He can't, I lose
That's how win rates drop rapidly when power drops ever so slightly, he's more likely to appear in extreme games which always skews the stats :)
But yeah, please buff Olaf back up =P
Wow, well. Guess there is a range of opinions on this...
I will punish swearing full stop. It's in the code, don't do it. That's mu view.
@Kantuti: Still a little confused on this all chat distinction, this guy wasn't talking in all chat for all the swearing...
"Now the game 2 is obvious punish, but game 3 is fine , and i'm neutral on game 1. So that's pretty clear pardon."
That attitude is exactly how this person got pardoned I guess, so I suppose that clears that up :) But you understand 'non toxic' games don't balance out the toxic ones right? It's not zero sum, but strict liability. What if your child was in that game?
you see nothing wrong with persistant swearing and calling people 'garbage' and 'retarded'?
That's against the summoners code, which we agree to to play, and certainly warrants punishment...
In any case, /all being normally disabled doesn't protect this toxic player's team mates from their toxicity, which is the real concern isn't it?
I loves me my tribunal, nothing more uplifiting than hitting punish on a toxic waste of space that the game is better off without :) And conversely, nothing beats pardoning the unfortunate vicitms if retaliation reporting!
I do not post on the pretty questionable decisions the community makes, until now. This case blew me away. I have always managed to find an explanation for why certain decisions are made. This ranges from; only the last games were toxic and therefore clearly not everybody read them all, certain 'moderate' swearing isn't punishable in some peoples eyes, calling people noobs when you carry hard is acceptable, etc etc.
This case, has none of those things. It blew my mind so hard that this was pardoned I felt the need to rant here and share this case, so here it is -
http://na.leagueoflegends.com/tribunal/case/6239522/#nogo
Am I crazy? Am I missing something? I know it's only 3 total reports in 3 games, with the last game actually being totally fine, but seriously! And a strong majority? Really? Really?
This slightly makes me worried that by introducing those 'I'm a human' tests the tribunal might actually become less effective =P
Quote from GentlemanGustaf »
Dearest VVinrar, if you wanted one of these, you could just have asked :P
oh GG, you're just stirring the pot aren't you =P
Alpha Team
Top - Voyboy (Curse, NA)
Mid - Froggen (Evil Geniuses, Europe)
Jungle - LilBallz (Taipei Assassins, Taiwan)
Support - Lustboy (Azubu Blaze, Korea)
AD Carry - Doublelift (CLG, NA)
Prime Team
Top - Maknoon (Najin Sword, Korea)
Mid - Alex Ich (Gambit Gaming, Europe)
Jungle - TheOddOne (TSM, NA)
Support - MadLife (Azubu Frost, Korea)
AD Carry - Weixiao (World Elite, China)
Quote from uncle_nashor »
realized its monsters only
Not sure whether you think this means it doesn't affect creeps? Becuase it does :) So while I wouldn't push the wriggles it isn't useless per se ;)
Actually, the life steal and armour with a smattering of damage... the free wards too... Maybe not that bad an idea in some very niche situations =P
