Quote from SiameseCookie »
Cait or Irelia. The first, look at the tournaments. The latter, still a monster once she has some items.
Uh....That's nothing to go on. These are 3 entirely separate champions for different roles. Caitlyn is a long range, early game and lane dominating AD that can take care of herself. Irelia is a tanky assassin champion that dives enemy teams with few weaknesses. Volibear is an early game lane tank of sorts and can jungle. I mean, your question doesn't really lend itself to anything. Asking what champion to get without anything else is just asking for a popularity contest of the day really.
Quote from KesslerCOIL »
in order of viability and power.
Caitlyn, Irelia, Volibear.
Caitlyn is one of the strongest ADC's currently.
Irelia is the strongest but still strong pick, dont first pick her though.
Volibear... he's just countered too easily
Imho, in order of most fun to play to least fun, Voli, Irelia, Cait.
In order of power, Irelia, Cait, Voli.
In order of Skill cap (Highest to lowest) Voli, Irelia, Cait.
In order of pure awesomeness. Voli(armored bear, 'nuff said), Irelia(better nerf her) Cait(As Vi puts it awesomely, 'Oh...look at me...I'm on the case.')
What they said.