I've just finished Season 1 of Boku Wa Tomodachi Ga Sukunai.
Please continue posting reccomendations in this thread, I read it and update it everytime I finish an anime!
Have seen all of
Bleach - I enjoy seeing the evolutions of the characters, just like Naruto. Enjoyed alot
Higurashi No Koro Ni
Claymore - Too short, but also good.
Clannad (Both seasons)
HOTD - Best of both worlds, very good.
Death Note - Very good.
Inuyasha - Personal favorite simply because it was the first anime I ever watched when I was much younger, About 9-10 years old.
Ao No Excorcist
Vampire Knight - 7/10 - Good, but had flaws
Guilty Crown - A m a z i n g
Angel Beats - Was cute, The ending was amazing, but they could have done some better things with the middle parts
Naruto Shippuden - Same as Bleach
Chunibuyou - Was very cute, Was weird getting into it, but from episodes 7 on it really paid off.
Code Geass - Evil Mastermind story, amazing.
Sword Art Online (Watching)
Accel World - was Meh
Mysterious Girlfriend X (LOVED IT) (one of favorites so far)
Darker Than Black S1 & S2
Mirai Nikki (One of my favorites so far, Just finished watching it, Was amazing)
Waiting for Next Seasons & Episodes
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai
I love long animes like Bleach & Naruto, but prefer it when they are quite advanced, I'm not really into pirates so One Piece has been something I've avoided.
I've probably seen more but I haven't listed them, If I think of any, I'll update the OP.
Going to watch:
Zero No Tsukaima
Did not like:
Cowboy Bebop- Watched up to about episode 12 and didn't enjoy the style.
Possibly going to watch:
(If I can find good links) Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya